Looking back, I wish I’d combined this post with the one I recently wrote about Sir Terry Pratchett. After all, Pratchett and the subject of today’s post, Niel Gaiman, were friends, collaborators and, by all accounts, shared a sense of humor.
More to the point, two of the books I read: Pratchett’s book of short stories and Gaiman’s Smoke and Mirrors are directly comparable. Both collect lesser known work by two great writers and will be of more than passing interest to anyone who’s already familiar with their major achievements.
Now, I’m not a Gaiman fan in the traditional sense. I haven’t read all that much of his work, other than Good Omens which I bought for the Pratchett content and enjoyed. In light of this, starting with the less-acclaimed shorter work might not seem like the sensible thing to do.
That, of course, has never stopped us before, so why begin now?
So, from this book, I can confidently say that I like some of Gaiman’s writing. Would I enjoy Sandman or American Gods? From this sample, I really have no clue. I always find graphic novels just a little thin and unfulfilling… American Gods is certainly more promising.
And Smoke and Mirrors? Definitely enjoyable, and the breadth of Gaiman’s interest in on display here. Some stories are, naturally more memorable than others but all display Gaiman’s love for the slightly surreal and his sense that nothing is so serious that fun cannot be poked in its direction. My kind of book.
It feels very similar to the Pratchett, somehow less solid than a novel-length work, but a very satisfying sprinkling.
Of the tales here, one of them sticks out as a nearly perfect example of… something. I’m not sure what, exactly it is, but if you want to decide for yourself, it’s entitled “The Goldfish Pool and Other Stories” (and you have to admire the kind of lunatic who would put “and Other Stories” in the title of his story, don’t you?). It’s a strange and wistful and surreal story. The ending wasn’t what I’d wanted it to be, but that might just have been the point. I still think of it often.
Of course, if you’re reading Gaiman, that’s because you haven’t seen him on YouTube. He is one of the most compelling public speakers I’ve ever seen. If you can take a certain dose of Michael Chabon (did he create the Hipster persona or just perfect it?) without throwing your device out the window, I highly recommend this interview in which Niel Gaiman discusses his relationship with Terry Pratchett in detail. It is mad and brilliant and still poignant and touching.
Anyway, this is a fun book, but I think the cool kids all started with Sandman, so that might be a good idea too…
Gustavo Bondoni’s is an Argentine writer whose latest novel, the Malakiad, is aimed squarely at those readers who miss Douglas Adams an Terry Pratchett and wish that there were more lunatics writing science fiction and fantasy. It’s available in paperback and Kindle editions.