Our Italianite period continues today with the review of one of the great Italian books of the 20th century. Now, other than Umberto Eco, I haven’t read that much modern Italian literature but, falling victim to the Folio Society’s beautiful marketing pitch and the fact that their books are utterly wonderful, I decided t purchase The Garden of the Finzi-Continis by Giorgio Bassani.
When reading the description, I expected to find a book very similar to Brideshead Revisited, which I loved. Instead, I found a book with a darker edge and an utter lack of the poetry of elegy. Of course, that might be down to the translation, but I didn’t feel that Waugh, as a writer and evoker of feelings, has anything to fear from Bassani.
Nevertheless, the book, which starts somewhat slowly, does become engrossing by the end, when things begin to unravel for the protagonists and the relationships between the young characters become a little more muddied.
Of course, we are told on the first page that the story has a sad ending, as it deals with a group of Jewish families on the eve of the Second World War. The impact was lessened in my case because it became impossible to fall in love with–or even to truly sympathize—with the mercurial Micòl, the narrator’s love interest. I generally have no problem falling head over heels for this kind of character, and what is basically a Holly Golightly character should, in my opinion, have been much more compelling.
But if the characters left me a bit cold, the same can’t be said of the setting. While the city of Ferrara as described by Bassani is unremarkable, the walled home of the titular family becomes a kind of unforgettable wonderland which lives on in memory long after the foibles of the characters are forgotten.
I haven’t seen the film based on the novel, perhaps it is better than the book when it comes to characters–what Micòl lacks in writing can be fixed by any decent casting director (sadly, it wasn’t… just did a google image search)–and I’d love to know what those of you who’ve seen it think.
Anyhow, if you enjoy unforgettable settings or different takes on the Holocaust, this one may be for you. Others might prefer to read Brideshead Revisited for the elegiac content or Breakfast at Tiffany’s for Micòl done right.
Gustavo Bondoni is an Argentine novelist and short story writer. He is the author of Siege, a far future science fiction book which explores what it means to be human–and why that definition matters. Buy it here!